Apple Is Playing Offense at WWDC

Apple is on the offensive. This is not a company content with standing by and letting Google, Facebook, Spotify and a handful of other third-parties take over critical elements of the user experience of approximately 500 million iPhone users. Instead of just swinging a sword and trying to compete with everyone indiscriminately, Apple is carefully positioning its resources and the overall iOS platform to stress value propositions at which Apple has historically excelled. These include personalization, emotion, and privacy. WWDC highlights how battles are being chosen meticulously as Apple's mission is clear: reducing its dependency on others. With the News app, Apple is trying to change users' habits in terms of how they get content. Apple Music is a test in how successful Apple will be once again in not just getting customers to pay for something that is free elsewhere, but rethinking the music industry. Siri and Spotlight are being positioned as Apple's method for rethinking search. Instead of sitting back and letting third-parties have all the fun, Apple wants more. 

The Chess Game Heading into WWDC

Apple had the wind at its back headed into this year's WWDC. The iPhone 6 and 6 Plus have resonated with consumers across the world, especially in China, leading to more than 40% unit growth year-to-date in 2015. One metric that Tim Cook has reiterated on recent earnings conference calls is the Android switcher rate, or the percent of iPhone sales that can be attributed to former Android users. Recent Kantar data and Above Avalon estimates would suggest that approximately 20-25% of iPhone sales in 2015 have come from customers new to iOS, which totals to nearly 25-30 million users entering the iOS ecosystem for the first time. 

The iOS platform has hit critical mass; it is large enough to sustain app innovation and developer interest. Nearly every major third-party consumer-facing technology company, including Google, Apple's primary competitor, have all but guaranteed support for the iOS platform, a noteworthy reversal from years of doubt and cynicism from those who warned Apple's smartphone 10% market share may eventually be outmatched by Android's massive reach. The problem with that logic turned out to be that Apple actually has 70%+ market share in the premium smartphone market which includes those who are very likely to use apps and services.

On top of that, Google and Facebook have business models that depend on obtaining data at scale, and Apple's highly engaged users are a prime target. It would be difficult, if not impossible, for Google and Facebook to ignore 500 million iPhone users

Given the current environment, one would assume Apple is feeling pretty good. Executives could push out an iOS refinement update, watch iPhone sales roll in, and coast along until WWDC 2016. In reality, Apple is more nervous now than ever before. 

This nervousness is not born from weakness, but rather strength. Apple is nervous about the unknown, the low probability event, the Black Swan that we can't even imagine. It is with this nervousness that Apple positioned certain new OS X and iOS 9 features as preemptive moves on the hypothetical chess board. 

Apple wants to be in a position where it can counter the scenario of Google, Facebook, or another powerful third-party taking over such a large amount of the user experience that Apple's relationship with the user is harmed. People are spending an increasing amount of time on social networks while music streaming is taking over. Even though both of these activities are not directly hurting Apple's financials, it's clear management wants to be better positioned to respond to each trend. 

While there are very few, if any, credible competitors that can truly ship software, services, and hardware at scale, it would be theoretically possible for a company to take user engagement on iOS and try to leverage it into a new direction using their own differentiated hardware. If Apple can position itself more strategically as a counter to third-party offerings, reducing its dependency on others, Apple could be in a better position to maintain the user experience and battle third-party apps and services in the future.

Fighting for Your Attention 

Although Apple may be seeing success in terms of smartphone sales, a fierce battle has been occurring for our attention once we turn on our gadgets.  Press and hold the iPhone home button and the battleground emerges: our home screen.  Software and services companies are each angling for our attention. Tech pundits often say Facebook's greatest threat is Google. Instead, Facebook's greatest threat is our short attention span. Services that largely do similar things are increasingly fighting for mind share in the areas of messaging, email, photo storage, and entertainment. When considering that a service can benefit from a network effect, the battle is only intensified as the apps and services with the most users achieve the best quality, thereby making it that much easier to attract new users. 

Whereas hardware manufacturers measure success by the 10s of millions of users, for software, success is now measured in 100s of millions. As more people spend more time on smartphones, the battle for our attention is only intensifying. It is for this reason that iOS is such an attractive proposition for companies craving reach and scale amongst premium users. 

In the early days of the iPhone, it was common to see a smartphone with lots of apps, each possessing a specific duty or job role. I created separate folders for social apps and news. Today, I still open my social app folder every day, but now my news folder has become irrelevant as I get most of my news from Twitter. This type of fierce competition for my attention is still playing out in area of social platforms and media brands, but it's clear that given the finite amount of attention, there will be winners and losers.  

With a suite of over 20 apps, Apple has relied on its vertical integration of shipping hardware, apps and services. In 2012, Apple jumped into maps. In 2014 Apple launched its health, fitness, and payments initiatives. And at this week's WWDC, Apple launched new News and Music apps, with rumors of a video service arriving sometime later this year or 2016. All of these services share one purpose: controlling our time and experience. They are meant to represent tasks or things that we do each day and to which Apple can add differentiation. One should not expect Apple to try to be the answer to everything, such as entering social media or other services that are inherently less fundamental to Apple's product line-up.

News

Apple's News app isn't so much a competitive jab at Facebook, but instead a hook for grabbing people's attention. Apple's description of the new app is quite clear: "News conveniently collects all the stories you want to read, from top news sources, based on topics you're most interested in - so you no longer need to move from app to app to stay informed." With News, Apple is trying to keep our attention just a little bit longer. Take a look at Facebook's Instant Articles and Snapchat's Discover to see what the war over attention is leading to. Technology companies are trying to shift commoditized news into a differentiated service meant to keep you within their properties.

This type of attention-holding strategy isn't new. In brick-and-mortar retail, Walmart includes various stores within its stores, such as vision centers, fast food restaurants, and medical clinics in an effort to get you inside a Walmart.  Similarly, Facebook wants people to spend more time within its apps by offering additional services, like news.

I don't view Apple as necessarily trying to rethink news or put other companies out of business. Instead, it is looked at as a tool to enrich the iOS platform while maintaining a closer relationship with the user. 

The risk in the strategy is that many users still have to go to Facebook, regardless of reading news. Going back to the Walmart analogy, it would be the equivalent of having to go to Walmart regardless of which medical clinic you visited. Chances are good you will end at the clinic inside Walmart rather than going across town to the stand-alone clinic. At the end of the day, the easiest path usually wins. It is for this reason that I think caution needs to be held before assuming News will be a runaway hit. Instead, I look at it as Apple moving a piece on the chess board, trying to gain a better competitive position in the future. 

Apple Music 

Apple's ambitions in music are underestimated. As Eddy Cue and Jimmy Iovine have made it very clear, Apple Music is not about music streaming, but rather a new music ecosystem meant to offer listeners across the world (100+ countries at launch) a place to not only access music, but become part of something bigger, interacting with musicians and receiving recommendations. Eddy Cue and Jimmy Iovine don't say it, but Apple Music is inherently built to keep your attention rather than just engage you in the physical act of listening to music. Technically speaking, Apple is now getting into content creation with its 24/7 radio station, Beats 1, as Zane Lowe will have a music show that contains interviews and other content. 

Connect, which will serve as a venue for musicians to connect with their fans, while distinct enough from the Ping disaster, contains just enough social media to make people begin wondering if there may be a bit more that meets the eye, where Connect can become a musician's first stop for sharing content. It is important to point out that despite Apple introducing new features that undoubtedly chase people's attention, the company is not being hostile to third-parties. Connect allows sharing through Facebook and Twitter. 

Apple Music is competing with the free streaming services of the world, including YouTube. While Apple may have indeed gotten people to pay for music once around (iTunes), it will be challenging for Apple to completely rethink the music industry without a free, ad-supported streaming option. Nevertheless, Apple is going to give it a try, positioning service and a new culture-defining internet radio option, as reasons customers will be willing to give Apple Music their attention and pay for something that can be gotten for free in the next app over.

Siri and Spotlight

We saw hints of Apple's ambitions in search last year, but this year's WWDC all but confirmed that Apple is quickly looking to distance itself from Google search.  

Apple's intentions on reducing its dependence on third-parties is not just limited to apps and software. All of Apple's new announcements related to an improved Siri and Spotlight, not to mention a new search API, are meant to have us move past Google dependence. In the process, Apple is able to build on its relationship with the user and not necessarily collect troves of data. Apple feels very confident that it doesn't need all of your data to produce "magic" as Phil Schiller described it. In reality, what Apple is suggesting is that it can produce an enjoyable environment that doesn't let technology overwhelm the user, yet still position the iPhone as a personal assistant. Apple calls it "intelligence," which is appropriately quite different from the connotations surrounding Google's "machine-learning" initiatives. 

Pushing Forward with iPad and Apple Watch Software

Apple’s mission hasn’t changed from its founding in the 1970s. As Jony Ive put it at the Condé Nast International Luxury Conference this past April, Apple has always been about making technology more personal. The primary way Apple will be able to continue going down that path is if they control our time and attention by selling gadgets filled with apps and services that we increasingly use to navigate the world. 

Nowhere is this strategy more apparent than Apple’s current product line-up, pieces of glass ranging from the Apple Watch to the iMac. At every stage in between, each product possesses a different function or role. This is the primary reason why Tim Cook hasn’t sounded the alarm about the iPad despite the product losing all of its sales momentum. For Apple, the iPad still has a role in the world. It’s just that a greater number of people are able to get their jobs done using iPhones and Macs. At WWDC, Apple all but assured us that a larger 12.9-inch iPad Plus will be released in the future with Split View, Slide Over, and picture-in-picture video. An iPad Plus isn't meant to turn around the iPad line, but instead serve a particular set of needs that can be answered with a multi-touch Force Touch-enabled large display. Some of Apple's products are simply more popular than others, based on screen size and mobility. Success isn't determined by the number of unit sales, but instead how effective a product is in addressing a particular set of problems. 

From Apple’s perspective, positioning the iPhone as a computer in our pocket is central to controlling our time because of how we are able to bring the iPhone mostly everywhere we go. Taking things further, in a quest to control even more of our time, what better way than to sell a computer that is literally on us?  The Apple Watch is Apple's first personalized piece of technology that can be worn. The outlook for native apps able to tap into much of the advanced components found in the Watch only validates Tim Cook's claim that the wrist is indeed a very interesting place. The day is still early with wearables, but Apple isn't waiting to push the envelope on what can be done on the wrist.    

WWDC 2016 and Beyond 

When considering Apple’s future, take a look at your daily calendar and at the activities that take up significant portions of your day. Anything from sleeping, watching TV, and commuting to and from work likely represent areas of interest for Apple. Of course, management is quite selective and as Tim Cook mentioned last year, executives actually spend most of their day debating what not to do. Apple is built on a model of placing very few big bets that can change the world, not lots of little bets very likely to fail but not likely to have much long-lasting impact. Apple's offensive strategy was on display at this year's WWDC including additional Siri capability, new and updated apps meant to hold user's attention, and a new Music platform positioned to regain music mindshare. Such tactical maneuvering is indicative that Apple is not pausing despite its improved market positioning when compared to Android. Apple is playing offense. 

If you enjoyed this article, you would love becoming an Above Avalon member. Receive exclusive analysis and perspective about Apple (10-12 articles a week delivered via a daily email). For more information and to become a member, visit the membership page