Apple 1Q13 Review; Thoughts on Guidance and AAPL

1Q13 Review

Apple’s 1Q13 results were largely in-line with my expectations.

• Revenues beat ($54.5 billion vs. my $53.1 billion)
• Margin beat (38.6% vs. my 37.9%)
• EPS beat ($13.81 vs. my $12.75)
• iPhone was an exact match (47.8 million - equal to my estimate)
• iPad was slightly stronger than expected (22.9 million vs. my 22.4 million)

While I was pleased with the quarter, my estimates were considered somewhat bearish compared to the crowd; so needless to say, there were more disappointed faces than smiles.  Apple reported healthy growth metrics for iPhone and iPad, while iPhone ASP remained strong and iPad ASP declined due to the iPad mini.  

2Q13 Guidance

Management altered the way guidance is presented. While the reasoning was not disclosed, I don’t think its much of a stretch to assume its management’s way of ending analysts’ nasty habit of severely overestimating guidance.  When Apple’s earnings report was initially released, the stock was trading in the $490-$495 range.  Guidance seemed to be of Apple’s conservative nature - in that case, guidance was O.K.  When Apple clarified that it would no longer give EPS guidance, but instead release ranges (including upper limits) for several line-items used to reach EPS, the stock quickly fell to the $460-$465 range as guidance was considered NOT O.K. (it can be debated what management meant by guidance ranges, but I am assuming Apple’s actual results will fall within these ranges). 

I didn’t find Apple’s 2Q13 guidance (with the new ranges) to be overly concerning. Going into the quarter, I knew 2Q13 was going to be tough due to difficult year-over-year comparisons to 2Q12. Judging from the stock’s decline, I guess I was in the minority. 

Did Anything Actually Change? 

Taking a step back from all of the earnings noise, I didn’t learn much new about Apple. Both iPhone and iPad unit growth is slowing, margin remains pressured due to newer products, and EPS growth will be difficult to achieve in 2013.  Minor details such as the iPhone 4 remaining supply-constrained (most likely due to limited resources and parts allocated to iPhone 4 production), iPad mini coming into supply/demand balance by the end of this quarter, and the mix between new and old iPhones remaining constant weren’t exactly market-moving data points.  

AAPL 

It is interesting to read the differing opinions on Apple’s quarter between the Valley’s reaction and that of Wall Street.  In the Valley’s eyes, Apple did great and is firing on all cylinders, but according to Wall Street, AAPL stock is broken as growth is slowing. I think reality is somewhere in the middle of those two extremes.  

AAPL has now been in a 4-month tailspin, including widespread shareholder rotation (meaning many of Apple’s shareholders as of the end of September are selling and being replaced by new shareholders). Such a rotation is often quite volatile, resulting in lower stock prices as the new shareholder base has different priorities and expectations for Apple (often of a lesser nature).  

Back in January 2012, the consensus view on Apple was that EPS from iPhone and iPad would plateau around $60. An additional premium for Apple optionality (i.e. new products) may push EPS to $70. P/E multiple and dividend payout ratios were then calculated accordingly.  Things certainly have changed.  The consensus view is now of Apple EPS topping out around $40. It’s tough for a stock labeled as *the* momentum tech growth story to keep its luster when EPS expectations are cut by 30%. Of course, investors and traders love to panic and overreact, so not only is Apple’s EPS problematic, but Apple’s business model is apparently broken, management is clueless, and the company is the new Microsoft. It is what it is and I don’t see a reason to fight it. 

Investors buying AAPL today (or for that matter - the past year) should not be buying it on iPhone and iPad predictions, but rather Apple’s ability to disrupt itself and introduce new product categories. Not surprisingly, when things are good and AAPL is up, everyone assumes Apple is in great shape. When AAPL is down, management is assumed to be inept; unable to innovate and remain relevant. 

Looking ahead, I think it will be difficult for Apple to report EPS growth in 2Q13 and 3Q13, due to tough year-over-year comparisons related to margins. Modest growth should come back in 4Q13 and moving into 2014.  I am assuming anyone with an earnings model is well aware of these trends, but judging from today’s stock price action, I may be too generous in my assumptions.  Catalysts such as China Mobile selling the iPhone (not in my model) or new products are most likely not being contemplated by Wall Street and one can argue even if catalysts come to fruition, many will simply brush them off as a non-event.  Just as funds had to own AAPL last year to beat certain performance benchmarks, many funds now have to sell AAPL because the stock is down. 

Many are trying to find rational answers with AAPL’s price action, but since the following statements are often true, I’m not sure how many answers are actually out there:

A stock often goes up because it has been going up. 

A stock often goes down because it has been going down. 

A stock’s valuation matters only when valuations start to matter. 

Fundamentals are important only when fundamentals become important. 

AAPL 1Q13 Preview; Near-Term Volatility Continuing

Revenue: $53.1 billion (AAPL guidance: $52.0 billion/Consensus: $54.5 billion) 

• I expect Apple’s revenue to increase 23% year-over-year after adjusting for the 14 weeks in 1Q12.

GM: 37.9% (AAPL guidance: 36.0%/Consensus: 38.4%)

• Apple’s margin is expected to decline sequentially from 4Q12 primarily due to the wide range of updated products. Margin remains a key near-term unknown for AAPL. Management’s 36% margin guidance is 870 basis points less than the 44.7% margin reported in 1Q12, making EPS growth difficult to achieve. I still include expanding margins throughout 2013.  Further weakness, or a shallower rebound, may result in an additional EPS growth headwind.

EPS: $12.75 (AAPL guidance: $11.75/Consensus: $13.33) 

• I expect Apple to report a 1% yoy EPS decline, when adjusting for 1Q12. While my $12.75 estimate is less than the Street’s $13.33 average, I attribute much of the variance to my lower gross margin expectation.

Product Unit Sales and Commentary

Macs: 5.2 million (flat yoy growth)

• Mac growth continues to slow as tablets and smartphones satisfy many consumers’ computing needs. I expect 10% growth in portables driven by holiday shopping to be mostly offset by nearly a 30% decline in desktop sales due to the new iMac release schedule.

iPad: 22.4 million (56% yoy growth - when adjusted for 1Q12)

• I expect Apple to report record iPad sales for 1Q13. My iPad estimate assumes approximately 8-10 million iPad minis and 12-13 million iPad 2 and fourth generation units. The iPad mini went on sale November 2 with an aggressive rollout, despite significant pent-up demand and limited supply. Apple was able to sell three million iPads in the three days following the iPad mini and fourth generation iPad launch. My estimate assumes approximately 25-35% cannibalization of the larger iPad models (1 out of 3 consumers willing to buy a larger iPad purchased an iPad mini instead). Going forward, I expect iPad mini sales to approach, if not exceed, those of the larger iPad models. 

iPod: 12.0 million (16% yoy decline)

iPhone: 47.8 million (39% yoy growth)

• Apple made significant progress in reaching supply/demand balance for iPhone 5 in the U.S. and other launch countries. My quarterly estimate is largely based on AT&T’s recent comments on October and November smartphone sales (and additional extrapolation). Historical averages for AT&T’s share of global iPhones (and assuming a slighter higher mix of international sales) would imply 40-50 million iPhone sales, which I would consider the high probability estimate range.  I then assume channel fill of at least 1 million units, which positions my estimate in the narrower 46-48 million estimate range. 

Apple has missed Wall Street consensus EPS for the past two quarters, and unless estimates come down in the following weeks, a third miss isn’t out of the question. While it is hard to point to any one factor as driving a fundamental change in Apple’s operating performance, Apple’s prior two quarters have contained a few concerning metrics, including contracting margins and declining iPad and iPhone growth.  Did the weak global economy finally catch up to Apple? Were product release cycles continuing to wreck havoc with consumer demand? 

The bear argument would label Apple’s two-year stretch from 2010-2011 as an outlier, when two new products (iPhone and iPad) produced a perfect storm for EPS explosion.  Going forward, bears would argue margins will decline further, effectively limiting EPS growth. Future products would then lack the size to move the EPS needle. 

The bull argument would focus on iPhone and iPad as product leaders in its respective industries, while a temporary margin drop is indicative of product updates and not a fundamental change in the operating landscape. Apple’s future product plans would also occupy a spot in the conversation. 

Will 1Q13 represent an AAPL inflection point? I don’t think one quarter is capable of shedding enough light to figure out where Apple stands in its long, storied history. With iPhone now entering its 6th year (iPod recently celebrated its 11th birthday), the days of 100% revenue growth may be over for the product line, but should that statement even be considered controversial? There is also evidence suggesting Apple may be looking to smooth out demand cycles by updating products more frequently, a move that may bring long-term benefits, but at short-term costs.    

While much of the recent AAPL discussion has been focused on slowing growth and falling margins, it is easy to overlook fundamentals that would be considered very strong for any Apple competitor:

• A smartphone pulling in $80 billion of revenue annually and growing at least 30%.
• A tablet pulling in $30 billion of revenue annually and growing at least 45%.

A few AAPL loyalists have recently declared another “bad” Apple quarter (where bad is judged merely by EPS) will signal a new Apple, an Apple not deserving of their attention and instead lumped in with the rest of the tech crowd.  I disagree. One quarter, especially in the midst of an obvious change in business performance (product updates and management reshuffling), is not enough to conclude the long-term Apple story has changed. If an investor wanted to run away from Apple for near-term volatility, that decision could have been made a few months ago. Continued margin volatility may produce a scenario where EPS growth can accelerate throughout the year and 2014, even with slowing product sales growth. 

AAPL’s next 3-5 years will depend on management’s ability to introduce new product categories into an ecosystem that values a set of beliefs, including two that I tried to put into words following my first days with an iPad:

That technology is too powerful of a force to enjoy without acquired perception and natural intelligence.

That product design has the power to momentarily satisfy the never-ending search for order and reason.

Quick Thoughts on Apple's Earnings

Apple reported another weak earnings report. Even though Apple plays the expectations game, I see no reason to spend time hating those involved in creating the game. Apple’s quarterly reports contain a lot of information, most of which is more suitable for tweets and random musings. I will leave all of the growth rates and other metrics to others and instead focus on the big picture.

Apple is still in the beginning of a massive capital investment phase (which has been detailed in 10Q and 10K filings).  In the span of four weeks, Apple updated practically its entire product line.  Few were expecting such widespread updates. While the iPhone 5 was the worst kept secret, as well as the rumored iPad mini, Apple surprised us with new iPods, new Macs, and a new iPad with Retina display.  All of these updates are taking a toll on the company in terms of upfront costs, hurting margins. The first iPhone 5 produced is more expensive than the Xth iPhone 5 produced next year. The same can be said for every updated Apple product. 

When thinking of massive capital investment plans, Disney comes to mind. As the U.S. economy was collapsing in 2008, Disney’s management team, which I regard as one of the most talented teams in this global economy, placed the bet that it was the right time to increase capital spend and make needed improvements to its Parks division. The stock market hated the idea (due to the unknown involved), but management stayed the course. Fast forward to 2012, Disney’s Parks margins are only now beginning to increase as guests enjoy the final product. Disney is now able to turn on the earnings faucet and reap the rewards. 

I think Apple is following a similar path. 

Once Apple perfects the processes required to make all of these new iGadgets, the costs will come down and margins will rise. The iPhone 5 form factor will most likely stay around for the new iPhone in 2013, helping margins. The iPad lineup will probably not see any additional revisions until next fall (when I expect a thinner and lighter iPad with Retina display). Constrained supplies will dissipate and the Apple earnings faucet will be operational once again. Additional implications include the high likelihood of no new Apple products until at least WWDC in June 2013, as well as continued lumpy quarterly earnings. Competition and component availability may also change product plans. In terms of modeling, I think Apple is becoming harder to forecast. I am afraid many independent (and professional) analysts will continue to forecast near-term earnings incorrectly as the number of input assumptions increase. Finally, I have been very public about my concern that product cycles were becoming too planned and orderly (i.e. iPad in March, iPhone in the fall), which artificially impacts demand as customers alter purchasing habits, but all of this is more noise than anything else, and these patterns eventually end.  

It doesn’t matter if Apple is a few dollars short of expected 1Q13 earnings or if iPad mini margins are a few 100 basis points lower than normal. Such details change from quarter to quarter. At the end of the day, Apple’s most important goal is making great products. Everything else is mostly noise.  

AAPL 4Q12 Estimate

Revenue: $36.2 billion (AAPL guidance: $34.0 billion/Consensus: $36.2 billion) 

• I expect iPad and iPhone to represent approximately 69% of Apple’s quarterly revenue.  

GM: 40.8% (AAPL guidance: 38.5%/Consensus: 40.4%)

• Apple’s margin will likely decline sequentially from 3Q12 due to the iPhone 5 and continued iPad 2 sales. A key question facing AAPL in the near-term is the margin run rate. In 2011, Apple reported a 40.5% gross margin, which increased to approximately 44% in 2012. Looking at 2013, I expect margins to decline a few hundred basis points to 42% related to the iPad mini and ongoing costs related to the iPhone’s new form factor.

EPS: $8.95 (AAPL guidance: $7.65/Consensus: $8.85) 

• I expect Apple to report 27% yoy EPS growth.  Interestingly, my $8.95 estimate is close to the Street’s $8.85 average, with 17 analysts projecting EPS higher than my $8.95. I attribute my low estimate to weaker iPhone sales, a lower iPhone average selling price (ASP), and a lower overall margin.

Product Unit Sales and Commentary

Macs: 5.5 million (12% yoy growth)

• Mac growth is slowing as tablets and smartphones satisfy many consumers’ computing needs. I expect double-digit growth in portables, driven by back-to-school purchases, to be partially offset by a modest decline in desktop sales due to stale models.

iPad: 18.4 million (65% yoy growth)

• I expect Apple to report record iPad sales for 4Q12. My iPad estimate assumes approximately 1.5 million iPads sold per week (including iPad 2 sales), which compares to the approximate 1.4 million weekly run rate last quarter. Supply/demand is in balance. Anecdotally, iPad 2 sales in education and business appear robust following the price cut, while lower component and manufacturing pricing should help limit drastic margin compression.

iPod: 6.1 million (8% yoy decline)

iPhone: 24.8 million (45% yoy growth)

• My estimate reflects 7 million iPhone 5 units and approximately 18 million iPhone 4S units (and to a lesser extent iPhone 4 and 3GS). Apple is currently suffering from a supply/demand imbalance for iPhone 5, which will limit sales in the near-term (including 1Q13). Other unknowns include the iPhone 4S sales run-rate prior to the iPhone 5 introduction and iPhone 4S popularity following the price drop. My 18 million iPhone 4S estimate reflects the impact from consumers delaying iPhone purchases ahead of the iPhone 5 release.  I am including a declining ASP due to robust iPhone 4S sales following the price drop (an observation partially derived from Verizon’s earnings which showed strong non-iPhone 5 sales, which I attribute to the price drop).  

When Apple releases earnings on October 25, investors will focus on product ASPs and margin. Publicized iPhone 5 supply shortages and iPad mini rumors should go a long way in explaining any moderate misses in iPhone and iPad unit sales, respectively. Nevertheless, any evidence of continued margin weakness and declining ASP in iPad and iPhone may push observers to reduce forward earnings, which have a high sensitivity to margins. A 100 basis point change in margin corresponds to a 3% change in Apple quarterly EPS.

AAPL 3Q12 Estimate

Revenue: $41.3 billion (AAPL guidance: $34.0 billion/Consensus: $37.4 billion) 

• I expect iPad and iPhone to represent approximately 75% of Apple’s quarterly revenue.  

GM: 45.5% (AAPL guidance: 41.5%/Consensus: 43.3%)

• Apple’s margin jumped to 47.4% last quarter, from 40.5% in 2011. Weaker iPhone sales should serve as a headwind for sequential quarterly GM expansion in 3Q12, although attractive component pricing will continue to provide support for yoy improvement (Apple reported 41.7% margin in 3Q11). 

EPS: $12.30 (AAPL guidance: $8.68/Consensus: $10.34) 

• I expect Apple to report 58% yoy EPS growth. 

Product Unit Sales and Commentary

Macs: 4.7 million (19% yoy growth)

• I expect Mac shipments to show continued strong yoy growth following updates to the laptop lineup at WWDC. Pent-up demand and early back-to-school purchases should help offset MacBook Pro with Retina display shortages.

iPad: 21.3 million (130% yoy growth)

• Apple will report record iPad sales for 3Q12. My iPad estimate assumes approximately 1.8 million iPads sold per week (including iPad 2 sales), which compares to the approximate 1.2 million weekly run rate during the last holiday quarter. Management commentary regarding continued iPad supply/demand imbalance bodes well for record iPad sales. Anecdotally, iPad 2 sales in education and business appear robust following the price cut, while lower component and manufacturing pricing should help to limit margin compression.

iPod: 6.6 million (13% yoy decline)

iPhone: 29.5 million (45% yoy growth)

• My estimate reflects an average 2.5 million weekly iPhone sales run rate. At the end of 2Q12, Apple reported 8.6 million iPhones in the channel inventory, a sequential increase of 2.6 million units. Backing out the inventory build, Apple reported an average 2.7 million weekly sales run rate last quarter. With supply/demand in balance and rumors of the new iPhone building, I expect the weekly sales run rate to decline into the fall.

When Apple releases earnings on July 24, iPad and iPhone sales, along with reported margin, will represent investor’s primary focal points. Apple’s prior commentary foreshadows a strong iPad quarter, surpassing the 15.3 million units sold in 1Q12. Any iPad sales number solidly above 17-19 million units will be looked at positively by the Street. With iPhone supply/demand having been in equilibrium for some time, Apple will not benefit from any significant inventory build this quarter, although carrier and country distribution expansion will result in solid yoy growth. Sell-side iPhone sales estimates have been set at somewhat realistic levels and one should not be surprised with sales between 25-30 million units, although iPhone sales estimates become somewhat irrelevant as we get closer to the new iPhone launch.